The Greatest 12r Shia Generation

They didn't exist at the time of the 11 imams.

Now I understand why 12rs get so angry when they are criticized. I mean don't we get angry when the 12rs criticize the sahaba ?
Likewise since the 12rs currently believe they are heavenly people so they do not want to hear anything on the contrary.

Refer to the 42:18 mark

12r Shia Lies Against Imam Abu Hanifa (ra)

The 12rs Shia nowadays are using questionable non-Shia sources to advance their opposition against Imam Abu Hanifa (ra). However, when we look into their source we can discover the reason why they have to rely on another school.



Also, here is what brother Inshallah an Admin posted on shiachat.

Your argument is like that of Abu Hanifa, once upon a time. That is, if I beat the hell out of you, I can claim in an Islamic court that it is not my fault since it was pre-destined and the will of Allah. You are ignoring historical references and introducing "fate" as an argument to prove your point. Feel free to do so but it holds no ground in an intellectual argument.
http://www.shiachat.com/forum/index.php?/topic/234992853-was-imam-ali-ra-forced-to-give-bayah/

The above belief is not a belief of Abu Hanifa (ra), but a lie fabricated by the 12r Shia sect.

Here is Abu Hanifa's ra view on man's action.

Abu Hanifa used to deal with this question in a restrained way. He believed in the decree of good and evil and the comprehensiveness of Allah’s knowledge, will and power in created beings. None of aperson’s actions are independent of Allah’s will even though man’s acts of obedience and disobedience are ascribed to him and he has choice and will in respect of them. He will be questioned and accountable forthem. He will not be wronged the weight of an atom. This is the Qur’anic dogma which is derived from Book.He debated with the Qadarites to cut them off. (Abu Hanifa, Abu Zahara)

Did Monafiqeen Exist in the Meccan Period of Islam ?

The 12rs say the sahaba became apostates after the demise of the Prophet :[S.A.W.W]:

However, my question to the 12rs is can you prove that the muhajireen among the sahaba who you consider as apostates or non-momin were non-Momin /borderline Muslims or monafiqeen during the Meccan period of Islam ?

As far as I know the term monafiqeen did not exist till migration to Madina took place.

So far I have ironically only seen the 12rs use Qiyas to justify their aqeeda, and their disassociation from the non-shias among the sahaba.

Shia Dream Narrations About How Bibi Fatima Died

What an amazing method to bring proof and find out if you are syed. Dream narrations are okay, but they are not strong evidence. As for the crying in the end, even the Yahoodi are good at that. Ask them about the holocaust and they were narrate you the events with their emotions. In fact, let's not forget how Muawiyah cried for Uthmaan (ra) death, so the people of Syria turn emotional and fight against Imam Ali (as).

Another Dream narration to prove that Shia Islam is correct.

By the way the above information is false. None of the Qari's sons are shia. They are still Sunni.

Ammar Nakshawani On the Status of Imam Ali (as) and Fatima (as) ?

Ok, I am not going to comment on this. I think he went overboard. Its not wonder the 12rs going out of control when they discuss issues like Fadak.

Use of Qiyas By The 12rs to Justify Their Extended Kalma

Its ironic how the 12r Shias claim that analogy is haraam in their sect. However, in most of their examples they actually use analogies to justify their beliefs. In the above clip Ammar Nakshawani uses an analogy to justify that the Kalma consists of 3 parts.