I've heard some 12ers Shia say that Abi Bakr(ra) stopped Bibi Fatima (as) from being buried beside the Prophet . Then they add that Imam Ali (as) dug a tunnel from jannat al Baqi to reach there because of Abi Bakr's (ra) rule.
So in their view we have both the Prophet and Bibi Fatima (sa) buried beside the Abi Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra).
I asked the 12ers what is the proof that Bibi Fatima (sa) should be buried beside Abi Bakr (ra) ? The 12ers said its common sense because that is part of inheritance.
I replied back by saying if it is common sense then I have about a dozen of questions to ask you.
If its common sense are any of Imam Ali's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Hassan's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Hussain's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Sajjad's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Baqir's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Sadiq's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Kazim's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Rida's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Taqi's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Naqi's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If its common sense are any of Imam Askari's (as) daughter(s) buried beside him ?
If the answer to all these question is no then please explain how this is common sense or part of inheritance as the 12er shia say?
The 12ers had no answer left.
Also, we must recall that be buried beside the Prophet is a big merit because Imam Hassan (as) himself asked Bibi Ayesha (ra) permission to have this privilege.
Of course the 12er version of this story about Bibi Ayesha (ra) arrow or opposing Imam Hassan (as) has been proven wrong umpteen amount of times.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment